Phantasy Star Cave Message Board

I've revised Phantasy Star Cave's timeline and put up a draft. The aim is to have a timeline that does not contradict the English or Japanese games, while omitting the revisionism of the Compendium. Since this is in English, the English names are used.

I haven't included Phantasy Star III yet, because it's either 1000 or 2000 years after Phantasy Star II.

Comments and suggestions welcome.

Really nice work so far!

Suggestion: Two columns to the left side of the date - E and J.
One or both contain a '*' to represent that the event in current line happened on that date in both or one version.
This way the line "Beginning of PSIII" will show up in two places.

-OR-

Just color the background of each line instead of two extra columns.
Blue for English, red for Japanese and yellow for both... for example...

I can't really decide which is better until I see/experience it.

In the years column just have the year displayed as AW 1384/1484 and have an asterisk explaining on the two years.

thriwren wrote:In the years column just have the year displayed as AW 1384/1484 and have an asterisk explaining on the two years.

You can't put dates in order if you do that. In that case either one is in wrong order. That's why I'd put same events with different date to seperate places to preserve the date order in both timelines. It's easier to follow both timelines then.

its a good draft sir

Zucca wrote:

thriwren wrote:In the years column just have the year displayed as AW 1384/1484 and have an asterisk explaining on the two years.

You can't put dates in order if you do that. In that case either one is in wrong order. That's why I'd put same events with different date to seperate places to preserve the date order in both timelines. It's easier to follow both timelines then.

True, but that would have double enteries of the same information.

Good work!!!!

It's about time someone did a proper timeline....

Lets all try and help with accuate information and not fill in the gaps with silly overstavations.

Also, it might be an idea to leave PS3 until the end.

1 2 and 4 would be the best starting point.

thriwren wrote:

Zucca wrote:<blah blah>

True, but that would have double enteries of the same information.

Unfortunately so. But I would still recommend it. :)

After all these years, I'm still wondering where the discrepancy actually came from.

We know English PSIII takes place 1000 years after the destruction of Parma as the elders from New Mota said so. But where do we get that Japanese PSIII takes place 1000 years later? Is it an assumption based on what's written in the Compendium?

BenoitRen wrote:After all these years, I'm still wondering where the discrepancy actually came from.

We know English PSIII takes place 1000 years after the destruction of Parma as the elders from New Mota said so. But where do we get that Japanese PSIII takes place 1000 years later? Is it an assumption based on what's written in the Compendium?

I am taking into the assumtion of the Dark for and 1000 year tradition. So I would put the Layan/orokian war was going on about the same time as (approx.) as PSIV.

thriwren wrote:

BenoitRen wrote:After all these years, I'm still wondering where the discrepancy actually came from.

I am taking into the assumtion of the Dark for and 1000 year tradition. So I would put the Layan/orokian war was going on about the same time as (approx.) as PSIV.

So in that theory PSIII happened actually bit later than PSIV?
Assuming that Dark Force boraded into Alisa III at the same time when PSIV started. After that Dark Force manipulated Laya and Orakio to start war against each other. Eventually they saw what was going on and started to plan deafeating Dark Force, but only succeed in capturing him/her into Orakio's sword. How long these wars lasted? And how long after that when Rhys found Maia from the beach?

Zucca wrote:

thriwren wrote:

BenoitRen wrote:After all these years, I'm still wondering where the discrepancy actually came from.

I am taking into the assumtion of the Dark for and 1000 year tradition. So I would put the Layan/orokian war was going on about the same time as (approx.) as PSIV.

So in that theory PSIII happened actually bit later than PSIV?
Assuming that Dark Force boraded into Alisa III at the same time when PSIV started. After that Dark Force manipulated Laya and Orakio to start war against each other. Eventually they saw what was going on and started to plan deafeating Dark Force, but only succeed in capturing him/her into Orakio's sword. How long these wars lasted? And how long after that when Rhys found Maia from the beach?

Or Dark force boarded the ship when Palm was destroyed and laid dormant.

Palm Exploded ---> Dark Force boarded Alisa III
Dark Force rests on Alisa III ---> Everything's OK, for now...
PSIV started ---> Things started to go wrong on Alisa III (Orakian and Layan wars)

Or how long after the explosion of Palma Dark Force boarded Alisa III? How long It took for him/her to destroy all the other world ships? I guess this is unknown? I guess he/she didn't just destroy all the ships in one day... More like several years... Maybe 1000 years until it was Alisa III's turn?

So:
Palm explosion ---> Dark Force splits at Noah (or there were already two of them) and goes after "easy targets" == world ships ---> ... which will took 1000 years to complete except for Alisa III where he/she is then captured ---> Some years after (from capturing of Dark Force by Orakio to the time of the last generation of PSIII) heroes at Alisa III defeats Dark Force, finally.

All this is just based on my poor memory. I don't actually remember if Laya and Orakio actually fought each other and Dark Force right after Palm explosion. And then if Dark Force was captured into Orakio's sword for next thousand years? That's the part I really cannot remember. How long did he/she was captured? I guess I have to play PSIII first generetion again, or look for some scripts.
There are too many open questions in the timeline for me.