Just played Kinds', Shilka's and Nei's and Amia's Adventures this weekend. Short but fun. Kinds' was probably the best, with Nei's a close second. Had Nei's not been a bit buggy (it's a remake, not a translation) I would probably have named it the winner. I never finished Amia's because it too is a remake, and it decided to hang up on me, but I've finished both Nei's and Amia's Adventures before.
The other two were new though. I must say that Shilka's Adventure was something of a disappointment. She's always been one of my favourite characters, but her expertise as a master-thief didn't get to show in the adventure. Most things seemed to happen by pure chance, not because of detailed planning, stealth and slight of hand.
Kinds' Adventure was cool, with a neat narrative and nice story. Only thing bugging me there was several references to Earthly phenomena, such as a Chinese restaurant...
Nei's Adventure was touching and cute. Essentially a good story on the theme of alienation. I didn't like their description of Paseo though.
Amia's Adventure is also neat, but maybe I'll save writing about that once I've finished it again. If you're curious but don't have the urge to play it, you can always read Darrell Whitney's "short storysation" of it here:
http://www.phantasy-star.net/fanfics/wh ... rdian.html
Next up (after Amia): Replaying Phantasy Star Adventure for GameGear. I've only played a Japanese version with a printed translation to guide me...